Bill: "I don't think I can support that feminist position. I think it is anti-male."
Jill: "So, you are not going to be with us on this one?"
Bill: "No."
Jill: "Either you are with us on this issue or you must be against all of our positions. So you must be against all of our positions. You are banned from the group."False DilemmaSlippery SlopeAppeal to the Consequences of a BeliefAppeal to FearFalse Dilemma is the right answer. Jill is assuming that Bill is either for all of the group's positions or against all of them. Assuming the group has more than one position, it is obviously possible for Bill to accept some and reject others. Hence her conclusion that Bill is against all the positions of the group is not warranted by the fact that Bill does not wish to accept the position in question.Slippery Slope is a wrong answer. No one is claiming that something must inevitably follow from something else.Appeal to the Consequences of a Belief is a wrong answer. No one is claiming that a claim should be accepted or rejected because of the direct effects of believing or rejecting the claim.Appeal to Fear is a wrong answer. While Jill might be attempting to scare Bill, she is not trying to convince Bill to accept a claim using something she hopes will induce fear in him as evidence.In this situation, Jill is assuming that Bill must either be one thing or another and that there is no third (or fourth, or fifth...) alternative.1